[Kermit]

Nice shot. I'm not into number ratings, but I'll give you my input here. The sun needs to be more towards the back of you to give better lighting on your subject(the car). There are very harsh shadows over the car in this shot. I'd also get down a tad lower so you see more sky and less ground. Maybe turn around the side of the car so you can see more of it. I'd suggest bumping your aperture up a smidge too to get a better DOF. Overall it's a cool shot. Nice car!

This post has been edited by Kermit: 21 December 2011 - 11:43 AM

[NZ.Joel]

9/10 I don't like how extreme the contrasts between the right side and the left side is.
Seems kinda silly, but it is just me.
I am still kinda new to photography, so don't take anything I say to heart.


(First attempt at editing)

This post has been edited by NZ.Joel: 26 December 2011 - 11:12 PM

[Kermit]

Well I'm not sure what you did in post editing but here are my thoughts-

Back up or zoom out. Your doggie has feet, make sure that they are in the photo!
Watch your focus. If you have a DSLR, find the continuous autofocus and use it!
Try and time it to wear the dog looks happy, not dead

Again, not into number ratings. You did pretty well on exposure and what not. Just work on framing and timing the subject.

[Trum_15]

8/10



DSC_0225 by Trum_15, on Flickr

[NZ.Joel]

It is an amazing photo, however I don't like how you can see the other Giraffe's neck, but nothing else from it. Also, that tree branch.
8.5 o.o

[Spyder PB Player]

7/10



Atrium by Notalenter, on Flickr

[Kermit]

Could be framed a tad better and it is under exposed, but nice poinsettias.

This post has been edited by Kermit: 09 January 2012 - 09:41 PM

[Marqman]

7/10 It's a bit dark to me. But I'm sure they loved the photo

[greenie]

6/10, maybe I'm just picky, but it's way over processed.


dogfence (1) by Eddieo92, on Flickr

[Marqman]

This thread gets no love, so I'll respond to you I'd say 4/10, It's a dog behind a fence the tree is extremely distracting and it's not very appealing although it is sharp and has a nice dof.

This post has been edited by Marqman: 28 January 2012 - 03:21 AM

[turkey357]

6/10

it seems a little too average and uninteresting, in short: it doesn't draw my eye maybe work on "rule of thirds" a little bit but i like how i can sense his height (while on the bike) pretty well..and the photo i was going to post isnt on my computer yet sorry

[Kermit]

[Blade of grass]

6-7/10 its a little plain, but i like the idea of it.


i just started talking some pictures, so give me some thoughts on this please. its using my friends dads D90 with a low light lens. i forgot to change the AF, so its a little blurry.
i forgot to add, this pales in comparison to most of yours, but it is one of my only pics on hand.

This post has been edited by Blade of grass: 17 February 2012 - 04:17 PM

[mokothemonkey]

6/10, Good concept but then angle seems to be just "Oh he is playing piano" so you point and shoot. I would either back up a bit and get some visual tension on the edges of the piano, or get in close on the hands playing. Maybe lower the Av to eliminate distractions in the background.




Edit: I don't really like the weighting of this photo, some suggestions on that specifically would be awesome

This post has been edited by mokothemonkey: 19 February 2012 - 05:39 PM

[Blade of grass]

9/10
the image isnt clear enough for my liking. i cant really give you any advice since im a novice photographer

or if you dont like that

This post has been edited by Blade of grass: 20 February 2012 - 06:00 PM

[Pakistani]

both are more snapshots really. 1st one wouldve been nice with a lower angle and the 2nd one is out of focus. 2/10 :-/

[littleloopy15]

I like it so Im gonna give it a 9/10. I cant say much more because I am new to photography. but here are my shots that I took with my friends D3100







Oops just read only one pic per post.

LMK what you guys think and what I can improve on. Thanks!

This post has been edited by littleloopy15: 23 February 2012 - 12:38 AM

[Blade of grass]

ok, lets see;
first one, i like! 7/10 (i dont know why, but it seems a little unfocused to me)
second one, 6/10, I don't really see anything in the shot that's interesting....
third one, 9/10, i think its framed well, (or at least the way i like it) and the way it is focused on the gun, and not anything else is cool.
finally, the forth, meh, i think that the third is much better, 4/10

yes it is just trees, but i like the way to beam of light goes across it. i think the ISO is a little high cause it looks grainy to me, (personal rating? 6/10) thought it is on manual focus, so it was pretty bright looking at to focus it.

This post has been edited by Blade of grass: 21 February 2012 - 06:01 PM

[Pakistani]

i think it might look better in your head than it actually does. good concept, but not all there. regardless of the ray of light, its a pretty uninteresting picture. 3/10.
keep it up though, taking nature shots is by no means easy.

more black and white from a recent trip to NYC.



NYCFB by AliZaman, on Flickr

[Chris@RegencyPB]

7.5/10